Naughty // Nice

1 printing · from $52.00 · pictured: Happy Holidays #12

€28.31

cheapest of 6 store offers · see all

market $52.00 (foil)

Mana cost: {1}{B}{B}{1}{W}{W}

Type: Sorcery // Sorcery

Search another target player's library for a card and put that card into your hand. Then shuffle that player's library.

Artist: Greg Staples

Released: 2012-12-01

Market price

  • TCGplayer foil: $52.00
  • Cardmarket foil: €28.31
  • MTGO tix: 0
232 days of daily prices for Naughty // Nice (foil): $64.57 to $52.00 $69.39 $52.00 2025-09-30 · foil $64.572025-09-30foil $64.57 2025-10-01 · foil $64.572025-10-01foil $64.57 2025-10-02 · foil $64.572025-10-02foil $64.57 2025-10-03 · foil $64.572025-10-03foil $64.57 2025-10-04 · foil $64.572025-10-04foil $64.57 2025-10-05 · foil $64.572025-10-05foil $64.57 2025-10-06 · foil $64.572025-10-06foil $64.57 2025-10-07 · foil $64.572025-10-07foil $64.57 2025-10-08 · foil $64.572025-10-08foil $64.57 2025-10-09 · foil $64.572025-10-09foil $64.57 2025-10-10 · foil $64.572025-10-10foil $64.57 2025-10-11 · foil $64.572025-10-11foil $64.57 2025-10-12 · foil $64.572025-10-12foil $64.57 2025-10-13 · foil $64.572025-10-13foil $64.57 2025-10-14 · foil $64.572025-10-14foil $64.57 2025-10-15 · foil $64.572025-10-15foil $64.57 2025-10-16 · foil $64.572025-10-16foil $64.57 2025-10-17 · foil $64.572025-10-17foil $64.57 2025-10-18 · foil $64.572025-10-18foil $64.57 2025-10-19 · foil $64.572025-10-19foil $64.57 2025-10-21 · foil $64.572025-10-21foil $64.57 2025-10-22 · foil $64.572025-10-22foil $64.57 2025-10-23 · foil $64.572025-10-23foil $64.57 2025-10-24 · foil $64.572025-10-24foil $64.57 2025-10-25 · foil $64.572025-10-25foil $64.57 2025-10-26 · foil $64.572025-10-26foil $64.57 2025-10-27 · foil $64.572025-10-27foil $64.57 2025-10-28 · foil $64.572025-10-28foil $64.57 2025-10-29 · foil $64.572025-10-29foil $64.57 2025-10-30 · foil $64.572025-10-30foil $64.57 2025-10-31 · foil $64.572025-10-31foil $64.57 2025-11-01 · foil $64.572025-11-01foil $64.57 2025-11-02 · foil $64.572025-11-02foil $64.57 2025-11-03 · foil $64.572025-11-03foil $64.57 2025-11-04 · foil $64.572025-11-04foil $64.57 2025-11-05 · foil $64.572025-11-05foil $64.57 2025-11-06 · foil $64.572025-11-06foil $64.57 2025-11-07 · foil $64.572025-11-07foil $64.57 2025-11-08 · foil $64.572025-11-08foil $64.57 2025-11-09 · foil $64.572025-11-09foil $64.57 2025-11-10 · foil $64.572025-11-10foil $64.57 2025-11-11 · foil $64.572025-11-11foil $64.57 2025-11-12 · foil $64.572025-11-12foil $64.57 2026-01-25 · foil $69.392026-01-25foil $69.39 2026-01-26 · foil $69.392026-01-26foil $69.39 2026-01-27 · foil $69.392026-01-27foil $69.39 2026-01-28 · foil $64.092026-01-28foil $64.09 2026-01-29 · foil $64.092026-01-29foil $64.09 2026-01-30 · foil $64.092026-01-30foil $64.09 2026-01-31 · foil $64.092026-01-31foil $64.09 2026-02-01 · foil $64.092026-02-01foil $64.09 2026-02-02 · foil $64.092026-02-02foil $64.09 2026-02-03 · foil $64.092026-02-03foil $64.09 2026-02-04 · foil $64.092026-02-04foil $64.09 2026-02-05 · foil $64.092026-02-05foil $64.09 2026-02-06 · foil $64.092026-02-06foil $64.09 2026-02-07 · foil $64.092026-02-07foil $64.09 2026-02-08 · foil $64.092026-02-08foil $64.09 2026-02-09 · foil $64.092026-02-09foil $64.09 2026-02-10 · foil $64.092026-02-10foil $64.09 2026-02-11 · foil $64.092026-02-11foil $64.09 2026-02-12 · foil $64.092026-02-12foil $64.09 2026-02-13 · foil $64.092026-02-13foil $64.09 2026-02-14 · foil $64.092026-02-14foil $64.09 2026-02-15 · foil $64.092026-02-15foil $64.09 2026-02-16 · foil $64.092026-02-16foil $64.09 2026-02-17 · foil $64.092026-02-17foil $64.09 2026-02-18 · foil $64.092026-02-18foil $64.09 2026-02-19 · foil $64.092026-02-19foil $64.09 2026-02-20 · foil $64.092026-02-20foil $64.09 2026-02-21 · foil $64.092026-02-21foil $64.09 2026-02-22 · foil $64.092026-02-22foil $64.09 2026-02-23 · foil $64.092026-02-23foil $64.09 2026-02-24 · foil $64.092026-02-24foil $64.09 2026-02-25 · foil $64.092026-02-25foil $64.09 2026-02-26 · foil $64.092026-02-26foil $64.09 2026-02-27 · foil $64.092026-02-27foil $64.09 2026-02-28 · foil $63.602026-02-28foil $63.60 2026-03-01 · foil $63.602026-03-01foil $63.60 2026-03-02 · foil $63.602026-03-02foil $63.60 2026-03-03 · foil $63.602026-03-03foil $63.60 2026-03-04 · foil $63.602026-03-04foil $63.60 2026-03-05 · foil $63.602026-03-05foil $63.60 2026-03-06 · foil $63.602026-03-06foil $63.60 2026-03-07 · foil $63.602026-03-07foil $63.60 2026-03-08 · foil $63.602026-03-08foil $63.60 2026-03-09 · foil $63.602026-03-09foil $63.60 2026-03-18 · foil $63.602026-03-18foil $63.60 2026-03-19 · foil $63.602026-03-19foil $63.60 2026-03-20 · foil $63.602026-03-20foil $63.60 2026-03-21 · foil $63.602026-03-21foil $63.60 2026-03-22 · foil $63.602026-03-22foil $63.60 2026-03-23 · foil $63.602026-03-23foil $63.60 2026-03-24 · foil $63.602026-03-24foil $63.60 2026-03-25 · foil $63.602026-03-25foil $63.60 2026-03-26 · foil $63.602026-03-26foil $63.60 2026-03-27 · foil $63.602026-03-27foil $63.60 2026-03-28 · foil $63.602026-03-28foil $63.60 2026-03-29 · foil $64.292026-03-29foil $64.29 2026-03-30 · foil $64.292026-03-30foil $64.29 2026-03-31 · foil $64.292026-03-31foil $64.29 2026-04-01 · foil $64.292026-04-01foil $64.29 2026-04-02 · foil $64.292026-04-02foil $64.29 2026-04-03 · foil $64.292026-04-03foil $64.29 2026-04-05 · foil $64.292026-04-05foil $64.29 2026-04-06 · foil $64.292026-04-06foil $64.29 2026-04-07 · foil $64.292026-04-07foil $64.29 2026-04-08 · foil $64.292026-04-08foil $64.29 2026-04-09 · foil $64.292026-04-09foil $64.29 2026-04-20 · foil $60.192026-04-20foil $60.19 2026-04-21 · foil $60.192026-04-21foil $60.19 2026-04-22 · foil $60.192026-04-22foil $60.19 2026-04-23 · foil $60.192026-04-23foil $60.19 2026-04-24 · foil $60.192026-04-24foil $60.19 2026-04-25 · foil $60.192026-04-25foil $60.19 2026-04-26 · foil $60.192026-04-26foil $60.19 2026-04-27 · foil $60.192026-04-27foil $60.19 2026-04-28 · foil $60.192026-04-28foil $60.19 2026-04-29 · foil $60.192026-04-29foil $60.19 2026-04-30 · foil $60.192026-04-30foil $60.19 2026-05-01 · foil $60.192026-05-01foil $60.19 2026-05-02 · foil $60.192026-05-02foil $60.19 2026-05-11 · foil $60.192026-05-11foil $60.19 2026-05-12 · foil $60.192026-05-12foil $60.19 2026-05-13 · foil $60.192026-05-13foil $60.19 2026-05-14 · foil $60.192026-05-14foil $60.19 2026-05-15 · foil $60.192026-05-15foil $60.19 2026-05-16 · foil $60.192026-05-16foil $60.19 2026-05-17 · foil $60.192026-05-17foil $60.19 2026-05-18 · foil $60.192026-05-18foil $60.19 2026-05-19 · foil $60.192026-05-19foil $60.19 2026-05-20 · foil $60.192026-05-20foil $60.19 2026-05-21 · foil $60.192026-05-21foil $60.19 2026-05-22 · foil $60.192026-05-22foil $60.19 2026-05-23 · foil $60.192026-05-23foil $60.19 2026-05-24 · foil $60.192026-05-24foil $60.19 2026-05-25 · foil $60.192026-05-25foil $60.19 2026-05-26 · foil $60.192026-05-26foil $60.19 2026-05-27 · foil $60.192026-05-27foil $60.19 2026-05-28 · foil $60.192026-05-28foil $60.19 2026-05-29 · foil $60.192026-05-29foil $60.19 2026-05-30 · foil $60.192026-05-30foil $60.19 2026-05-31 · foil $60.192026-05-31foil $60.19 2026-06-01 · foil $60.192026-06-01foil $60.19 2026-06-02 · foil $60.192026-06-02foil $60.19 2026-06-03 · foil $60.192026-06-03foil $60.19 2026-06-04 · foil $60.192026-06-04foil $60.19 2026-06-05 · foil $60.192026-06-05foil $60.19 2026-06-06 · foil $60.192026-06-06foil $60.19 2026-06-07 · foil $60.192026-06-07foil $60.19 2026-06-08 · foil $60.192026-06-08foil $60.19 2026-06-09 · foil $60.192026-06-09foil $60.19 2026-06-10 · foil $60.192026-06-10foil $60.19 2026-06-11 · foil $60.192026-06-11foil $60.19 2026-06-12 · foil $60.192026-06-12foil $60.19 2026-06-13 · foil $60.192026-06-13foil $60.19 2026-06-14 · foil $60.192026-06-14foil $60.19 2026-06-15 · foil $60.192026-06-15foil $60.19 2026-06-16 · foil $60.192026-06-16foil $60.19 2026-06-17 · foil $60.192026-06-17foil $60.19 2026-06-18 · foil $60.192026-06-18foil $60.19 2026-06-19 · foil $60.192026-06-19foil $60.19 2026-06-20 · foil $60.192026-06-20foil $60.19 2026-06-21 · foil $60.192026-06-21foil $60.19 2026-06-22 · foil $58.492026-06-22foil $58.49 2026-06-23 · foil $58.492026-06-23foil $58.49 2026-06-24 · foil $58.492026-06-24foil $58.49 2026-06-25 · foil $58.492026-06-25foil $58.49 2026-06-26 · foil $58.492026-06-26foil $58.49 2026-07-24 · foil $58.492026-07-24foil $58.49 2026-07-25 · foil $58.492026-07-25foil $58.49 2026-07-26 · foil $58.492026-07-26foil $58.49 2026-07-27 · foil $58.492026-07-27foil $58.49 2026-07-28 · foil $58.492026-07-28foil $58.49 2026-07-29 · foil $58.492026-07-29foil $58.49 2026-07-30 · foil $58.492026-07-30foil $58.49 2026-07-31 · foil $58.492026-07-31foil $58.49 2026-08-01 · foil $58.492026-08-01foil $58.49 2026-08-02 · foil $58.492026-08-02foil $58.49 2026-08-03 · foil $58.492026-08-03foil $58.49 2026-08-04 · foil $58.492026-08-04foil $58.49 2026-08-05 · foil $58.492026-08-05foil $58.49 2026-08-06 · foil $58.492026-08-06foil $58.49 2026-08-07 · foil $58.492026-08-07foil $58.49 2026-08-08 · foil $58.492026-08-08foil $58.49 2026-08-09 · foil $58.492026-08-09foil $58.49 2026-08-10 · foil $58.492026-08-10foil $58.49 2026-08-11 · foil $58.492026-08-11foil $58.49 2026-08-12 · foil $58.492026-08-12foil $58.49 2026-08-13 · foil $58.492026-08-13foil $58.49 2026-08-14 · foil $58.492026-08-14foil $58.49 2026-08-15 · foil $58.492026-08-15foil $58.49 2026-08-16 · foil $58.492026-08-16foil $58.49 2026-08-17 · foil $58.492026-08-17foil $58.49 2026-08-18 · foil $58.492026-08-18foil $58.49 2026-08-19 · foil $58.492026-08-19foil $58.49 2026-08-20 · foil $58.492026-08-20foil $58.49 2026-08-21 · foil $58.492026-08-21foil $58.49 2026-08-22 · foil $58.492026-08-22foil $58.49 2026-08-23 · foil $58.492026-08-23foil $58.49 2026-08-24 · foil $58.492026-08-24foil $58.49 2026-08-25 · foil $58.492026-08-25foil $58.49 2026-08-28 · foil $58.492026-08-28foil $58.49 2026-08-29 · foil $58.492026-08-29foil $58.49 2026-08-30 · foil $58.492026-08-30foil $58.49 2026-08-31 · foil $58.492026-08-31foil $58.49 2026-09-01 · foil $58.492026-09-01foil $58.49 2026-09-02 · foil $58.492026-09-02foil $58.49 2026-09-03 · foil $58.492026-09-03foil $58.49 2026-09-04 · foil $58.492026-09-04foil $58.49 2026-09-05 · foil $58.492026-09-05foil $58.49 2026-09-06 · foil $58.492026-09-06foil $58.49 2026-09-08 · foil $58.492026-09-08foil $58.49 2026-09-09 · foil $58.492026-09-09foil $58.49 2026-09-10 · foil $58.492026-09-10foil $58.49 2026-09-11 · foil $58.492026-09-11foil $58.49 2026-09-12 · foil $58.492026-09-12foil $58.49 2026-09-13 · foil $58.492026-09-13foil $58.49 2026-09-14 · foil $58.492026-09-14foil $58.49 2026-09-15 · foil $58.492026-09-15foil $58.49 2026-09-16 · foil $58.492026-09-16foil $58.49 2026-09-17 · foil $58.492026-09-17foil $58.49 2026-09-19 · foil $58.492026-09-19foil $58.49 2026-09-20 · foil $58.492026-09-20foil $58.49 2026-09-21 · foil $58.492026-09-21foil $58.49 2026-09-22 · foil $58.492026-09-22foil $58.49 2026-09-23 · foil $58.492026-09-23foil $58.49 2026-09-24 · foil $58.492026-09-24foil $58.49 2026-09-25 · foil $52.002026-09-25foil $52.00 2026-09-26 · foil $52.002026-09-26foil $52.00 2026-09-27 · foil $52.002026-09-27foil $52.00 2026-09-28 · foil $52.002026-09-28foil $52.00 2025-09-30 2026-09-28
foil · 232 days tracked · $64.57 → $52.00 (-19%) · low $52.00 · high $69.39
Daily USD snapshots; a flat stretch is a day with no new price recorded.

Store prices

The 3 cheapest per condition and finish, in stock at the last check. Offers not re-confirmed within 60 days are not shown.

StoreConditionFinishPriceChecked
CardmarketNM · foil · todayNMfoil€28.31today
Face To Face GamesSP · foil · todaySPfoilCA$39.99today
Face To Face GamesNM · foil · todayNMfoilCA$49.99today
House Of CardsSP · todaySPregularCA$76.10today
Mana MarketNM · foil · yesterdayNMfoil83.00 AUDyesterday
House Of CardsNM · todayNMregularCA$84.50today

Format legality

  • standard: not legal
  • pioneer: not legal
  • modern: not legal
  • legacy: not legal
  • vintage: not legal
  • commander: not legal
  • pauper: not legal
  • brawl: not legal

All printings

Set#RarityUSD
Happy Holidays#12 · rare12rare$52.00 foil