Thalia, Heretic Cathar

11 printings · from $0.21 to $6.11 · pictured: Secret Lair Drop #1428

Market history and store offers below are for Secret Lair Drop #1428; the range above covers the listed printings.

$3.99

cheapest of 6 store offers · see all

market $6.11

Mana cost: {2}{W}

Type: Legendary Creature — Human Soldier

First strike
Creatures and nonbasic lands your opponents control enter tapped.

Artist: Rian Gonzales

Released: 2025-03-24

Market price

  • TCGplayer: $6.11
  • Cardmarket foil (converted): $6.19
  • Cardmarket: €4.69
  • Cardmarket foil: €5.43
  • MTGO tix: 0
231 days of daily prices for Thalia, Heretic Cathar: $3.40 to $6.11 $6.19 $3.02 2025-09-27 · regular $3.40 · foil $3.942025-09-27regular $3.40foil $3.94 2025-09-28 · regular $3.402025-09-28regular $3.40 2025-09-30 · regular $3.41 · foil $4.082025-09-30regular $3.41foil $4.08 2025-10-01 · regular $3.522025-10-01regular $3.52 2025-10-02 · regular $3.602025-10-02regular $3.60 2025-10-03 · regular $3.602025-10-03regular $3.60 2025-10-04 · regular $3.60 · foil $4.072025-10-04regular $3.60foil $4.07 2025-10-05 · regular $3.602025-10-05regular $3.60 2025-10-06 · regular $3.612025-10-06regular $3.61 2025-10-07 · regular $3.61 · foil $3.802025-10-07regular $3.61foil $3.80 2025-10-08 · regular $3.572025-10-08regular $3.57 2025-10-09 · regular $3.572025-10-09regular $3.57 2025-10-10 · regular $3.59 · foil $3.832025-10-10regular $3.59foil $3.83 2025-10-11 · regular $3.582025-10-11regular $3.58 2025-10-12 · regular $3.602025-10-12regular $3.60 2025-10-13 · regular $3.61 · foil $3.822025-10-13regular $3.61foil $3.82 2025-10-14 · regular $3.632025-10-14regular $3.63 2025-10-15 · regular $3.632025-10-15regular $3.63 2025-10-16 · regular $3.64 · foil $4.032025-10-16regular $3.64foil $4.03 2025-10-17 · regular $3.642025-10-17regular $3.64 2025-10-18 · regular $3.642025-10-18regular $3.64 2025-10-19 · regular $3.64 · foil $4.032025-10-19regular $3.64foil $4.03 2025-10-21 · regular $3.642025-10-21regular $3.64 2025-10-22 · regular $3.70 · foil $3.702025-10-22regular $3.70foil $3.70 2025-10-23 · regular $3.702025-10-23regular $3.70 2025-10-24 · regular $3.692025-10-24regular $3.69 2025-10-25 · regular $3.73 · foil $3.712025-10-25regular $3.73foil $3.71 2025-10-26 · regular $3.742025-10-26regular $3.74 2025-10-27 · regular $3.742025-10-27regular $3.74 2025-10-28 · regular $3.742025-10-28regular $3.74 2025-10-29 · regular $3.74 · foil $3.752025-10-29regular $3.74foil $3.75 2025-10-30 · regular $3.702025-10-30regular $3.70 2025-10-31 · regular $3.702025-10-31regular $3.70 2025-11-01 · regular $3.702025-11-01regular $3.70 2025-11-02 · regular $3.70 · foil $3.932025-11-02regular $3.70foil $3.93 2025-11-03 · regular $3.702025-11-03regular $3.70 2025-11-04 · regular $3.702025-11-04regular $3.70 2025-11-05 · regular $3.712025-11-05regular $3.71 2025-11-06 · regular $3.71 · foil $3.842025-11-06regular $3.71foil $3.84 2025-11-07 · regular $3.742025-11-07regular $3.74 2025-11-08 · regular $3.802025-11-08regular $3.80 2025-11-09 · regular $3.822025-11-09regular $3.82 2025-11-10 · regular $3.82 · foil $4.212025-11-10regular $3.82foil $4.21 2025-11-11 · regular $3.822025-11-11regular $3.82 2025-11-12 · regular $3.762025-11-12regular $3.76 2026-01-25 · regular $4.51 · foil $3.192026-01-25regular $4.51foil $3.19 2026-01-26 · regular $4.51 · foil $3.172026-01-26regular $4.51foil $3.17 2026-01-27 · regular $4.55 · foil $3.162026-01-27regular $4.55foil $3.16 2026-01-28 · regular $4.56 · foil $3.132026-01-28regular $4.56foil $3.13 2026-01-29 · regular $4.56 · foil $3.132026-01-29regular $4.56foil $3.13 2026-01-30 · regular $4.56 · foil $3.082026-01-30regular $4.56foil $3.08 2026-01-31 · regular $4.56 · foil $3.022026-01-31regular $4.56foil $3.02 2026-02-01 · regular $4.56 · foil $3.132026-02-01regular $4.56foil $3.13 2026-02-02 · regular $4.56 · foil $3.142026-02-02regular $4.56foil $3.14 2026-02-03 · regular $4.59 · foil $3.152026-02-03regular $4.59foil $3.15 2026-02-04 · regular $4.64 · foil $3.112026-02-04regular $4.64foil $3.11 2026-02-05 · regular $4.64 · foil $3.112026-02-05regular $4.64foil $3.11 2026-02-06 · regular $4.53 · foil $3.112026-02-06regular $4.53foil $3.11 2026-02-07 · regular $4.54 · foil $3.112026-02-07regular $4.54foil $3.11 2026-02-08 · regular $4.54 · foil $3.112026-02-08regular $4.54foil $3.11 2026-02-09 · regular $4.57 · foil $3.112026-02-09regular $4.57foil $3.11 2026-02-10 · regular $4.57 · foil $3.082026-02-10regular $4.57foil $3.08 2026-02-11 · regular $4.57 · foil $3.032026-02-11regular $4.57foil $3.03 2026-02-12 · regular $4.57 · foil $3.052026-02-12regular $4.57foil $3.05 2026-02-13 · regular $4.57 · foil $3.052026-02-13regular $4.57foil $3.05 2026-02-14 · regular $4.57 · foil $3.052026-02-14regular $4.57foil $3.05 2026-02-15 · regular $4.57 · foil $3.052026-02-15regular $4.57foil $3.05 2026-02-16 · regular $4.57 · foil $3.052026-02-16regular $4.57foil $3.05 2026-02-17 · regular $4.57 · foil $3.052026-02-17regular $4.57foil $3.05 2026-02-18 · regular $4.62 · foil $3.312026-02-18regular $4.62foil $3.31 2026-02-19 · regular $4.64 · foil $3.322026-02-19regular $4.64foil $3.32 2026-02-20 · regular $4.64 · foil $3.622026-02-20regular $4.64foil $3.62 2026-02-21 · regular $4.64 · foil $3.622026-02-21regular $4.64foil $3.62 2026-02-22 · regular $4.61 · foil $3.562026-02-22regular $4.61foil $3.56 2026-02-23 · regular $4.61 · foil $3.552026-02-23regular $4.61foil $3.55 2026-02-24 · regular $4.59 · foil $3.552026-02-24regular $4.59foil $3.55 2026-02-25 · regular $4.59 · foil $3.562026-02-25regular $4.59foil $3.56 2026-02-26 · regular $4.59 · foil $3.552026-02-26regular $4.59foil $3.55 2026-02-27 · regular $4.59 · foil $4.022026-02-27regular $4.59foil $4.02 2026-02-28 · regular $4.59 · foil $4.012026-02-28regular $4.59foil $4.01 2026-03-01 · regular $4.54 · foil $4.182026-03-01regular $4.54foil $4.18 2026-03-02 · regular $4.54 · foil $4.192026-03-02regular $4.54foil $4.19 2026-03-03 · regular $4.54 · foil $4.212026-03-03regular $4.54foil $4.21 2026-03-04 · regular $4.54 · foil $4.252026-03-04regular $4.54foil $4.25 2026-03-05 · regular $4.53 · foil $4.252026-03-05regular $4.53foil $4.25 2026-03-06 · regular $4.53 · foil $4.262026-03-06regular $4.53foil $4.26 2026-03-07 · regular $4.51 · foil $4.352026-03-07regular $4.51foil $4.35 2026-03-08 · regular $4.51 · foil $4.352026-03-08regular $4.51foil $4.35 2026-03-09 · regular $4.51 · foil $4.372026-03-09regular $4.51foil $4.37 2026-03-18 · regular $4.51 · foil $4.372026-03-18regular $4.51foil $4.37 2026-03-19 · regular $4.54 · foil $4.852026-03-19regular $4.54foil $4.85 2026-03-20 · regular $4.54 · foil $4.832026-03-20regular $4.54foil $4.83 2026-03-21 · regular $4.55 · foil $4.822026-03-21regular $4.55foil $4.82 2026-03-22 · regular $4.55 · foil $4.822026-03-22regular $4.55foil $4.82 2026-03-23 · regular $4.55 · foil $4.822026-03-23regular $4.55foil $4.82 2026-03-24 · regular $4.57 · foil $4.802026-03-24regular $4.57foil $4.80 2026-03-25 · regular $4.57 · foil $4.802026-03-25regular $4.57foil $4.80 2026-03-26 · regular $4.57 · foil $4.812026-03-26regular $4.57foil $4.81 2026-03-27 · regular $4.58 · foil $4.822026-03-27regular $4.58foil $4.82 2026-03-28 · regular $4.58 · foil $4.842026-03-28regular $4.58foil $4.84 2026-03-29 · regular $4.58 · foil $4.842026-03-29regular $4.58foil $4.84 2026-03-30 · regular $4.58 · foil $4.842026-03-30regular $4.58foil $4.84 2026-03-31 · regular $4.60 · foil $4.862026-03-31regular $4.60foil $4.86 2026-04-01 · regular $4.60 · foil $4.832026-04-01regular $4.60foil $4.83 2026-04-02 · regular $4.63 · foil $4.802026-04-02regular $4.63foil $4.80 2026-04-03 · regular $4.63 · foil $4.832026-04-03regular $4.63foil $4.83 2026-04-05 · regular $4.62 · foil $4.832026-04-05regular $4.62foil $4.83 2026-04-06 · regular $4.64 · foil $4.842026-04-06regular $4.64foil $4.84 2026-04-07 · regular $4.64 · foil $4.822026-04-07regular $4.64foil $4.82 2026-04-08 · regular $4.64 · foil $4.792026-04-08regular $4.64foil $4.79 2026-04-20 · regular $4.72 · foil $4.832026-04-20regular $4.72foil $4.83 2026-04-21 · regular $4.72 · foil $4.812026-04-21regular $4.72foil $4.81 2026-04-22 · regular $4.72 · foil $4.832026-04-22regular $4.72foil $4.83 2026-04-23 · regular $4.83 · foil $4.842026-04-23regular $4.83foil $4.84 2026-04-24 · regular $4.83 · foil $4.852026-04-24regular $4.83foil $4.85 2026-04-25 · regular $4.86 · foil $4.782026-04-25regular $4.86foil $4.78 2026-04-26 · regular $4.86 · foil $4.782026-04-26regular $4.86foil $4.78 2026-04-27 · regular $4.86 · foil $4.782026-04-27regular $4.86foil $4.78 2026-04-28 · regular $4.86 · foil $4.772026-04-28regular $4.86foil $4.77 2026-04-29 · regular $4.86 · foil $4.782026-04-29regular $4.86foil $4.78 2026-04-30 · regular $4.83 · foil $4.792026-04-30regular $4.83foil $4.79 2026-05-01 · regular $4.86 · foil $4.832026-05-01regular $4.86foil $4.83 2026-05-02 · regular $4.90 · foil $4.832026-05-02regular $4.90foil $4.83 2026-05-11 · regular $5.062026-05-11regular $5.06 2026-05-12 · regular $5.062026-05-12regular $5.06 2026-05-13 · regular $5.06 · foil $4.662026-05-13regular $5.06foil $4.66 2026-05-14 · regular $5.09 · foil $4.672026-05-14regular $5.09foil $4.67 2026-05-15 · regular $5.19 · foil $4.682026-05-15regular $5.19foil $4.68 2026-05-16 · regular $5.19 · foil $4.702026-05-16regular $5.19foil $4.70 2026-05-17 · regular $5.16 · foil $4.702026-05-17regular $5.16foil $4.70 2026-05-18 · regular $5.14 · foil $4.712026-05-18regular $5.14foil $4.71 2026-05-19 · regular $5.15 · foil $4.882026-05-19regular $5.15foil $4.88 2026-05-20 · regular $5.15 · foil $4.892026-05-20regular $5.15foil $4.89 2026-05-21 · regular $5.15 · foil $4.732026-05-21regular $5.15foil $4.73 2026-05-22 · regular $5.15 · foil $4.732026-05-22regular $5.15foil $4.73 2026-05-23 · regular $5.15 · foil $4.732026-05-23regular $5.15foil $4.73 2026-05-24 · regular $5.15 · foil $4.702026-05-24regular $5.15foil $4.70 2026-05-25 · regular $5.15 · foil $4.692026-05-25regular $5.15foil $4.69 2026-05-26 · regular $5.15 · foil $4.562026-05-26regular $5.15foil $4.56 2026-05-27 · regular $5.15 · foil $4.522026-05-27regular $5.15foil $4.52 2026-05-28 · regular $5.15 · foil $4.522026-05-28regular $5.15foil $4.52 2026-05-29 · regular $5.15 · foil $4.522026-05-29regular $5.15foil $4.52 2026-05-30 · regular $5.15 · foil $4.382026-05-30regular $5.15foil $4.38 2026-05-31 · regular $5.13 · foil $4.382026-05-31regular $5.13foil $4.38 2026-06-01 · regular $5.14 · foil $4.392026-06-01regular $5.14foil $4.39 2026-06-02 · regular $5.14 · foil $4.392026-06-02regular $5.14foil $4.39 2026-06-03 · regular $5.16 · foil $4.392026-06-03regular $5.16foil $4.39 2026-06-04 · regular $5.10 · foil $4.402026-06-04regular $5.10foil $4.40 2026-06-05 · regular $5.10 · foil $4.402026-06-05regular $5.10foil $4.40 2026-06-06 · regular $5.10 · foil $4.422026-06-06regular $5.10foil $4.42 2026-06-07 · regular $5.10 · foil $4.422026-06-07regular $5.10foil $4.42 2026-06-08 · regular $5.10 · foil $4.432026-06-08regular $5.10foil $4.43 2026-06-09 · regular $5.11 · foil $4.432026-06-09regular $5.11foil $4.43 2026-06-10 · regular $5.11 · foil $4.422026-06-10regular $5.11foil $4.42 2026-06-11 · regular $5.11 · foil $4.432026-06-11regular $5.11foil $4.43 2026-06-12 · regular $5.11 · foil $4.292026-06-12regular $5.11foil $4.29 2026-06-13 · regular $5.11 · foil $4.292026-06-13regular $5.11foil $4.29 2026-06-14 · regular $5.11 · foil $4.292026-06-14regular $5.11foil $4.29 2026-06-15 · regular $5.11 · foil $4.282026-06-15regular $5.11foil $4.28 2026-06-16 · regular $5.11 · foil $4.282026-06-16regular $5.11foil $4.28 2026-06-17 · regular $5.11 · foil $4.272026-06-17regular $5.11foil $4.27 2026-06-18 · regular $5.11 · foil $4.292026-06-18regular $5.11foil $4.29 2026-06-19 · regular $5.11 · foil $4.322026-06-19regular $5.11foil $4.32 2026-06-20 · regular $5.02 · foil $4.322026-06-20regular $5.02foil $4.32 2026-06-21 · regular $5.02 · foil $4.452026-06-21regular $5.02foil $4.45 2026-06-22 · regular $5.02 · foil $4.452026-06-22regular $5.02foil $4.45 2026-06-23 · regular $5.02 · foil $4.462026-06-23regular $5.02foil $4.46 2026-06-24 · regular $5.02 · foil $4.482026-06-24regular $5.02foil $4.48 2026-06-25 · regular $5.02 · foil $4.322026-06-25regular $5.02foil $4.32 2026-06-26 · regular $5.02 · foil $4.312026-06-26regular $5.02foil $4.31 2026-07-24 · regular $5.02 · foil $4.152026-07-24regular $5.02foil $4.15 2026-07-25 · regular $5.02 · foil $4.152026-07-25regular $5.02foil $4.15 2026-07-26 · regular $5.02 · foil $4.202026-07-26regular $5.02foil $4.20 2026-07-27 · regular $5.02 · foil $4.202026-07-27regular $5.02foil $4.20 2026-07-28 · regular $5.02 · foil $4.202026-07-28regular $5.02foil $4.20 2026-07-29 · regular $5.00 · foil $4.202026-07-29regular $5.00foil $4.20 2026-07-30 · regular $5.00 · foil $4.192026-07-30regular $5.00foil $4.19 2026-07-31 · regular $5.00 · foil $4.152026-07-31regular $5.00foil $4.15 2026-08-01 · regular $4.98 · foil $4.732026-08-01regular $4.98foil $4.73 2026-08-02 · regular $4.98 · foil $4.732026-08-02regular $4.98foil $4.73 2026-08-03 · regular $5.01 · foil $4.722026-08-03regular $5.01foil $4.72 2026-08-04 · regular $5.01 · foil $4.732026-08-04regular $5.01foil $4.73 2026-08-05 · regular $5.01 · foil $4.732026-08-05regular $5.01foil $4.73 2026-08-06 · regular $4.99 · foil $4.722026-08-06regular $4.99foil $4.72 2026-08-07 · regular $4.99 · foil $4.732026-08-07regular $4.99foil $4.73 2026-08-08 · regular $4.99 · foil $4.722026-08-08regular $4.99foil $4.72 2026-08-09 · regular $4.99 · foil $4.722026-08-09regular $4.99foil $4.72 2026-08-10 · regular $4.99 · foil $4.722026-08-10regular $4.99foil $4.72 2026-08-11 · regular $4.99 · foil $4.722026-08-11regular $4.99foil $4.72 2026-08-12 · regular $4.99 · foil $4.722026-08-12regular $4.99foil $4.72 2026-08-13 · regular $5.10 · foil $4.562026-08-13regular $5.10foil $4.56 2026-08-14 · regular $5.11 · foil $4.562026-08-14regular $5.11foil $4.56 2026-08-15 · regular $5.11 · foil $4.552026-08-15regular $5.11foil $4.55 2026-08-16 · regular $5.11 · foil $4.552026-08-16regular $5.11foil $4.55 2026-08-17 · regular $5.11 · foil $4.552026-08-17regular $5.11foil $4.55 2026-08-18 · regular $5.11 · foil $4.552026-08-18regular $5.11foil $4.55 2026-08-19 · regular $5.06 · foil $4.552026-08-19regular $5.06foil $4.55 2026-08-20 · regular $5.08 · foil $4.522026-08-20regular $5.08foil $4.52 2026-08-21 · regular $5.22 · foil $4.512026-08-21regular $5.22foil $4.51 2026-08-22 · regular $5.22 · foil $4.512026-08-22regular $5.22foil $4.51 2026-08-23 · regular $5.41 · foil $4.512026-08-23regular $5.41foil $4.51 2026-08-24 · regular $5.41 · foil $4.512026-08-24regular $5.41foil $4.51 2026-08-25 · regular $5.41 · foil $4.522026-08-25regular $5.41foil $4.52 2026-08-28 · regular $5.44 · foil $4.522026-08-28regular $5.44foil $4.52 2026-08-29 · regular $5.44 · foil $4.542026-08-29regular $5.44foil $4.54 2026-08-30 · regular $5.44 · foil $4.752026-08-30regular $5.44foil $4.75 2026-08-31 · regular $5.44 · foil $4.882026-08-31regular $5.44foil $4.88 2026-09-01 · regular $5.44 · foil $4.882026-09-01regular $5.44foil $4.88 2026-09-02 · regular $5.49 · foil $4.952026-09-02regular $5.49foil $4.95 2026-09-03 · regular $5.52 · foil $4.962026-09-03regular $5.52foil $4.96 2026-09-04 · regular $5.56 · foil $4.942026-09-04regular $5.56foil $4.94 2026-09-05 · regular $5.66 · foil $4.942026-09-05regular $5.66foil $4.94 2026-09-06 · regular $5.81 · foil $4.802026-09-06regular $5.81foil $4.80 2026-09-08 · regular $5.89 · foil $4.792026-09-08regular $5.89foil $4.79 2026-09-09 · regular $5.89 · foil $4.792026-09-09regular $5.89foil $4.79 2026-09-10 · regular $5.89 · foil $4.792026-09-10regular $5.89foil $4.79 2026-09-11 · regular $5.892026-09-11regular $5.89 2026-09-12 · regular $6.01 · foil $4.802026-09-12regular $6.01foil $4.80 2026-09-13 · regular $6.03 · foil $4.612026-09-13regular $6.03foil $4.61 2026-09-14 · regular $6.03 · foil $4.612026-09-14regular $6.03foil $4.61 2026-09-15 · regular $6.03 · foil $4.632026-09-15regular $6.03foil $4.63 2026-09-16 · regular $6.03 · foil $4.642026-09-16regular $6.03foil $4.64 2026-09-17 · regular $6.03 · foil $4.652026-09-17regular $6.03foil $4.65 2026-09-19 · regular $6.03 · foil $4.912026-09-19regular $6.03foil $4.91 2026-09-20 · regular $6.03 · foil $4.912026-09-20regular $6.03foil $4.91 2026-09-21 · regular $6.03 · foil $4.912026-09-21regular $6.03foil $4.91 2026-09-22 · regular $6.03 · foil $4.922026-09-22regular $6.03foil $4.92 2026-09-23 · regular $6.03 · foil $4.922026-09-23regular $6.03foil $4.92 2026-09-24 · regular $6.03 · foil $4.952026-09-24regular $6.03foil $4.95 2026-09-25 · regular $6.11 · foil $4.772026-09-25regular $6.11foil $4.77 2026-09-26 · regular $6.11 · foil $6.192026-09-26regular $6.11foil $6.19 2025-09-27 2026-09-26
regular foil · 231 days tracked · $3.40 → $6.11 (+80%) · low $3.02 · high $6.19
Daily USD snapshots; a flat stretch is a day with no new price recorded.

Store prices

The 3 cheapest per condition and finish, in stock at the last check. Offers not re-confirmed within 60 days are not shown.

StoreConditionFinishPriceChecked
Card KingdomNM · foil · 3 days agoNMfoil$3.993 days ago
CardTraderNM · 37 days agoNMregular€4.0637 days ago
CardTraderNM · foil · 37 days agoNMfoil€4.5637 days ago
CardmarketNM · todayNMregular€4.69today
CardmarketNM · foil · todayNMfoil€5.43today
CardTraderSP · 37 days agoSPregular€10.8937 days ago

Format legality

  • standard: not legal
  • pioneer: legal
  • modern: legal
  • legacy: legal
  • vintage: legal
  • commander: legal
  • pauper: not legal
  • brawl: legal

From the community

2 versions proposed by community members (2 copies in total).

Sign in to see who has them

In Gestic collections

  • Held in 67 lists
  • Played in 2 decks

Decks that play this card

Browse all decks

All printings

Set#RarityUSD
Secret Lair Drop#1428 · rare1428rare$6.11
Innistrad Remastered#351 · rare351rare$1.15
Innistrad Remastered#44 · rare44rare$2.14
Innistrad Remastered Art Series#2 · common2common$0.21
Innistrad Remastered#300 · rare300rare$2.01
Shadows over Innistrad Remastered#49 · rare49rare—
Secret Lair Countdown#2016 · rare2016rare$5.36
Magic Online Promos#61545 · rare61545rare—
Eldritch Moon#46 · rare46rare$2.07
Eldritch Moon Promos#46s · rare46srare$5.66 foil
Eldritch Moon Promos#46 · rare46rare$2.64 foil