Toothy, Imaginary Friend

4 printings · from $4.38 to $22.82 · pictured: The List #BBD-12

Market history and store offers below are for The List #BBD-12; the range above covers the listed printings.

$4.50

cheapest of 3 store offers · see all

market $4.38

Mana cost: {3}{U}

Type: Legendary Creature — Illusion

Commonly played as: Draw, Tutor

Partner with Pir, Imaginative Rascal (When this creature enters, target player may put Pir into their hand from their library, then shuffle.)
Whenever you draw a card, put a +1/+1 counter on Toothy.
When Toothy leaves the battlefield, draw a card for each +1/+1 counter on it.

Artist: Zoltan Boros

Released: 2026-10-19

Market price

  • TCGplayer: $4.38
  • Cardmarket: €7.88
  • MTGO tix: 0
$11.83$4.38
52 days of daily prices for Toothy, Imaginary Friend: $11.30 to $4.38
2026-09-232026-11-13
52 days tracked · $11.30 → $4.38 (-61%) · low $4.38 · high $11.83
Daily USD snapshots; a flat stretch is a day with no new price recorded.

Store prices

The 3 cheapest per condition and finish, in stock at the last check. Offers not re-confirmed within 60 days are not shown. Prices in different currencies are compared at the current exchange rate.

StoreConditionFinishPriceChecked
ManaPoolSP · todaySPregular$4.50today
ManaPoolNM · todayNMregular$5.25today
CardmarketNM · todayNMregular€8.08today

Format legality

  • standard: not legal
  • pioneer: not legal
  • modern: not legal
  • legacy: legal
  • vintage: legal
  • commander: legal
  • pauper: not legal
  • brawl: not legal

In Gestic collections

  • Held in 16 lists

All printings

Set#RarityUSD
The List#BBD-12 · rareBBD-12rare$4.38
Secret Lair Drop#1049 · rare1049rare$22.82
Battlebond#12 · rare12rare$11.55
Battlebond Promos#12s · rare12srare$15.66 foil