€1212.37
cheapest of 3 store offers · see all
market $1399.99
Mana cost: {5} {B}
Type: Creature — Nightmare Horse
Flying (This creature can't be blocked except by creatures with flying or reach.) Nightmare's power and toughness are each equal to the number of Swamps you control.
Artist: Melissa A. Benson
Released: 1993-08-05
Finishes: Nonfoil
Market price
TCGplayer: $1399.99
Cardmarket: €1225.14
MTGO tix: 0
187 days of daily prices for Nightmare: $1442.88 to $1399.99
$1442.88
$1014.80
2025-11-11 · regular $1442.88 2025-11-11 regular $1442.88
2026-01-25 · regular $1031.62 2026-01-25 regular $1031.62
2026-01-26 · regular $1026.63 2026-01-26 regular $1026.63
2026-01-27 · regular $1023.52 2026-01-27 regular $1023.52
2026-01-28 · regular $1015.34 2026-01-28 regular $1015.34
2026-01-29 · regular $1014.80 2026-01-29 regular $1014.80
2026-01-30 · regular $1015.21 2026-01-30 regular $1015.21
2026-01-31 · regular $1021.44 2026-01-31 regular $1021.44
2026-02-01 · regular $1021.09 2026-02-01 regular $1021.09
2026-02-02 · regular $1023.89 2026-02-02 regular $1023.89
2026-02-03 · regular $1027.85 2026-02-03 regular $1027.85
2026-02-04 · regular $1028.50 2026-02-04 regular $1028.50
2026-02-05 · regular $1028.55 2026-02-05 regular $1028.55
2026-02-06 · regular $1030.17 2026-02-06 regular $1030.17
2026-02-07 · regular $1028.42 2026-02-07 regular $1028.42
2026-02-08 · regular $1028.59 2026-02-08 regular $1028.59
2026-02-09 · regular $1027.86 2026-02-09 regular $1027.86
2026-02-10 · regular $1020.92 2026-02-10 regular $1020.92
2026-02-11 · regular $1021.03 2026-02-11 regular $1021.03
2026-02-12 · regular $1022.22 2026-02-12 regular $1022.22
2026-02-13 · regular $1023.02 2026-02-13 regular $1023.02
2026-02-14 · regular $1023.50 2026-02-14 regular $1023.50
2026-02-15 · regular $1023.55 2026-02-15 regular $1023.55
2026-02-16 · regular $1023.63 2026-02-16 regular $1023.63
2026-02-17 · regular $1024.74 2026-02-17 regular $1024.74
2026-02-18 · regular $1025.86 2026-02-18 regular $1025.86
2026-02-19 · regular $1028.49 2026-02-19 regular $1028.49
2026-02-20 · regular $1031.77 2026-02-20 regular $1031.77
2026-02-21 · regular $1031.17 2026-02-21 regular $1031.17
2026-02-22 · regular $1031.43 2026-02-22 regular $1031.43
2026-02-23 · regular $1028.41 2026-02-23 regular $1028.41
2026-02-24 · regular $1029.98 2026-02-24 regular $1029.98
2026-02-25 · regular $1031.29 2026-02-25 regular $1031.29
2026-02-26 · regular $1029.08 2026-02-26 regular $1029.08
2026-02-27 · regular $1029.07 2026-02-27 regular $1029.07
2026-02-28 · regular $1028.43 2026-02-28 regular $1028.43
2026-03-01 · regular $1028.66 2026-03-01 regular $1028.66
2026-03-02 · regular $1060.93 2026-03-02 regular $1060.93
2026-03-03 · regular $1066.94 2026-03-03 regular $1066.94
2026-03-04 · regular $1075.38 2026-03-04 regular $1075.38
2026-03-05 · regular $1073.56 2026-03-05 regular $1073.56
2026-03-06 · regular $1076.12 2026-03-06 regular $1076.12
2026-03-07 · regular $1077.04 2026-03-07 regular $1077.04
2026-03-08 · regular $1077.22 2026-03-08 regular $1077.22
2026-03-09 · regular $1081.94 2026-03-09 regular $1081.94
2026-03-18 · regular $1083.20 2026-03-18 regular $1083.20
2026-03-19 · regular $1086.94 2026-03-19 regular $1086.94
2026-03-20 · regular $1082.25 2026-03-20 regular $1082.25
2026-03-21 · regular $1081.14 2026-03-21 regular $1081.14
2026-03-22 · regular $1081.07 2026-03-22 regular $1081.07
2026-03-23 · regular $1080.50 2026-03-23 regular $1080.50
2026-03-24 · regular $1077.16 2026-03-24 regular $1077.16
2026-03-25 · regular $1077.10 2026-03-25 regular $1077.10
2026-03-26 · regular $1078.98 2026-03-26 regular $1078.98
2026-03-27 · regular $1081.86 2026-03-27 regular $1081.86
2026-03-28 · regular $1084.37 2026-03-28 regular $1084.37
2026-03-29 · regular $1084.26 2026-03-29 regular $1084.26
2026-03-30 · regular $1086.34 2026-03-30 regular $1086.34
2026-03-31 · regular $1089.32 2026-03-31 regular $1089.32
2026-04-01 · regular $1083.16 2026-04-01 regular $1083.16
2026-04-02 · regular $1077.18 2026-04-02 regular $1077.18
2026-04-03 · regular $1082.13 2026-04-03 regular $1082.13
2026-04-05 · regular $1083.57 2026-04-05 regular $1083.57
2026-04-06 · regular $1084.55 2026-04-06 regular $1084.55
2026-04-07 · regular $1082.00 2026-04-07 regular $1082.00
2026-04-08 · regular $1075.07 2026-04-08 regular $1075.07
2026-04-09 · regular $1069.70 2026-04-09 regular $1069.70
2026-04-20 · regular $1063.08 2026-04-20 regular $1063.08
2026-04-21 · regular $1060.41 2026-04-21 regular $1060.41
2026-04-22 · regular $1063.06 2026-04-22 regular $1063.06
2026-04-23 · regular $1065.43 2026-04-23 regular $1065.43
2026-04-24 · regular $1068.36 2026-04-24 regular $1068.36
2026-04-25 · regular $1066.64 2026-04-25 regular $1066.64
2026-04-26 · regular $1066.76 2026-04-26 regular $1066.76
2026-04-27 · regular $1067.00 2026-04-27 regular $1067.00
2026-04-28 · regular $1064.99 2026-04-28 regular $1064.99
2026-04-29 · regular $1066.83 2026-04-29 regular $1066.83
2026-04-30 · regular $1068.68 2026-04-30 regular $1068.68
2026-05-01 · regular $1065.88 2026-05-01 regular $1065.88
2026-05-02 · regular $1065.36 2026-05-02 regular $1065.36
2026-05-13 · regular $1064.06 2026-05-13 regular $1064.06
2026-05-14 · regular $1066.32 2026-05-14 regular $1066.32
2026-05-15 · regular $1069.33 2026-05-15 regular $1069.33
2026-05-16 · regular $1074.02 2026-05-16 regular $1074.02
2026-05-17 · regular $1073.79 2026-05-17 regular $1073.79
2026-05-18 · regular $1074.91 2026-05-18 regular $1074.91
2026-05-19 · regular $1072.25 2026-05-19 regular $1072.25
2026-05-20 · regular $1075.70 2026-05-20 regular $1075.70
2026-05-21 · regular $1075.69 2026-05-21 regular $1075.69
2026-05-22 · regular $1075.82 2026-05-22 regular $1075.82
2026-05-23 · regular $1076.51 2026-05-23 regular $1076.51
2026-05-24 · regular $1076.65 2026-05-24 regular $1076.65
2026-05-25 · regular $1074.05 2026-05-25 regular $1074.05
2026-05-26 · regular $1073.08 2026-05-26 regular $1073.08
2026-05-27 · regular $1073.76 2026-05-27 regular $1073.76
2026-05-28 · regular $1073.89 2026-05-28 regular $1073.89
2026-05-29 · regular $1072.85 2026-05-29 regular $1072.85
2026-05-30 · regular $1071.25 2026-05-30 regular $1071.25
2026-05-31 · regular $1399.99 2026-05-31 regular $1399.99
2026-06-01 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-01 regular $1399.99
2026-06-02 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-02 regular $1399.99
2026-06-03 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-03 regular $1399.99
2026-06-04 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-04 regular $1399.99
2026-06-05 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-05 regular $1399.99
2026-06-06 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-06 regular $1399.99
2026-06-07 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-07 regular $1399.99
2026-06-08 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-08 regular $1399.99
2026-06-09 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-09 regular $1399.99
2026-06-10 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-10 regular $1399.99
2026-06-11 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-11 regular $1399.99
2026-06-12 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-12 regular $1399.99
2026-06-13 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-13 regular $1399.99
2026-06-14 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-14 regular $1399.99
2026-06-15 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-15 regular $1399.99
2026-06-16 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-16 regular $1399.99
2026-06-17 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-17 regular $1399.99
2026-06-18 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-18 regular $1399.99
2026-06-19 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-19 regular $1399.99
2026-06-20 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-20 regular $1399.99
2026-06-21 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-21 regular $1399.99
2026-06-22 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-22 regular $1399.99
2026-06-23 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-23 regular $1399.99
2026-06-24 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-24 regular $1399.99
2026-06-25 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-25 regular $1399.99
2026-06-26 · regular $1399.99 2026-06-26 regular $1399.99
2026-07-24 · regular $1399.99 2026-07-24 regular $1399.99
2026-07-25 · regular $1399.99 2026-07-25 regular $1399.99
2026-07-26 · regular $1399.99 2026-07-26 regular $1399.99
2026-07-27 · regular $1399.99 2026-07-27 regular $1399.99
2026-07-28 · regular $1399.99 2026-07-28 regular $1399.99
2026-07-29 · regular $1399.99 2026-07-29 regular $1399.99
2026-07-30 · regular $1399.99 2026-07-30 regular $1399.99
2026-07-31 · regular $1399.99 2026-07-31 regular $1399.99
2026-08-01 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-01 regular $1399.99
2026-08-02 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-02 regular $1399.99
2026-08-03 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-03 regular $1399.99
2026-08-04 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-04 regular $1399.99
2026-08-05 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-05 regular $1399.99
2026-08-06 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-06 regular $1399.99
2026-08-07 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-07 regular $1399.99
2026-08-08 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-08 regular $1399.99
2026-08-09 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-09 regular $1399.99
2026-08-10 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-10 regular $1399.99
2026-08-11 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-11 regular $1399.99
2026-08-12 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-12 regular $1399.99
2026-08-13 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-13 regular $1399.99
2026-08-14 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-14 regular $1399.99
2026-08-15 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-15 regular $1399.99
2026-08-16 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-16 regular $1399.99
2026-08-17 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-17 regular $1399.99
2026-08-18 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-18 regular $1399.99
2026-08-19 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-19 regular $1399.99
2026-08-20 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-20 regular $1399.99
2026-08-21 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-21 regular $1399.99
2026-08-22 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-22 regular $1399.99
2026-08-23 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-23 regular $1399.99
2026-08-24 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-24 regular $1399.99
2026-08-25 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-25 regular $1399.99
2026-08-28 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-28 regular $1399.99
2026-08-29 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-29 regular $1399.99
2026-08-30 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-30 regular $1399.99
2026-08-31 · regular $1399.99 2026-08-31 regular $1399.99
2026-09-01 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-01 regular $1399.99
2026-09-02 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-02 regular $1399.99
2026-09-03 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-03 regular $1399.99
2026-09-04 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-04 regular $1399.99
2026-09-05 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-05 regular $1399.99
2026-09-06 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-06 regular $1399.99
2026-09-08 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-08 regular $1399.99
2026-09-09 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-09 regular $1399.99
2026-09-10 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-10 regular $1399.99
2026-09-11 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-11 regular $1399.99
2026-09-12 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-12 regular $1399.99
2026-09-13 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-13 regular $1399.99
2026-09-14 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-14 regular $1399.99
2026-09-15 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-15 regular $1399.99
2026-09-16 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-16 regular $1399.99
2026-09-17 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-17 regular $1399.99
2026-09-19 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-19 regular $1399.99
2026-09-20 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-20 regular $1399.99
2026-09-21 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-21 regular $1399.99
2026-09-22 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-22 regular $1399.99
2026-09-23 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-23 regular $1399.99
2026-09-24 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-24 regular $1399.99
2026-09-25 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-25 regular $1399.99
2026-09-26 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-26 regular $1399.99
2026-09-27 · regular $1399.99 2026-09-27 regular $1399.99
2025-11-11
2026-09-27
187 days tracked · $1442.88 → $1399.99 (-3%) · low $1014.80 · high $1442.88 Daily USD snapshots; a flat stretch is a day with no new price recorded.
Other languages
The same printing (Limited Edition Alpha #118) in 10 other languages.
Store prices
The 3 cheapest per condition and finish, in stock at the last check. Offers not re-confirmed within 60 days are not shown.
Store Condition Finish Price Checked
CardTrader HP · today HP regular €1212.37 today
Cardmarket NM · today NM regular €1225.14 today
Card Kingdom MP · today MP regular $2099.99 today
Format legality
standard: not legal
pioneer: legal
modern: legal
legacy: legal
vintage: legal
commander: legal
pauper: not legal
brawl: legal
In Gestic collections
Held in 1 lists
1 copies tracked
All printings of Nightmare
USD · low $0.15 · high $1668.36
Showing 24 of 30 printings · see all with prices