Traumatic Critique

Secrets of Strixhaven · #358 · rare · EN

CA$0.99

cheapest of 18 store offers · see all

market $1.27

Mana cost: {X}{U}{R}

Type: Instant

Commonly played as: Removal, Draw, Burn

Traumatic Critique deals X damage to any target. Draw two cards, then discard a card.

Artist: Aaron Miller

Released: 2026-04-24

Finishes: Nonfoil, Foil

Market price

  • TCGplayer: $1.27
  • TCGplayer foil: $1.42
  • Cardmarket: €1.42
  • Cardmarket foil: €1.62
  • MTGO tix: 1.03
125 days of daily prices for Traumatic Critique: $28.00 to $1.27 $60.00 $0.88 2026-04-05 · regular $28.00 · foil $60.002026-04-05regular $28.00foil $60.00 2026-04-06 · regular $26.00 · foil $60.002026-04-06regular $26.00foil $60.00 2026-04-07 · regular $23.50 · foil $60.002026-04-07regular $23.50foil $60.00 2026-04-20 · regular $3.56 · foil $3.432026-04-20regular $3.56foil $3.43 2026-04-21 · regular $2.34 · foil $3.332026-04-21regular $2.34foil $3.33 2026-04-22 · regular $2.36 · foil $3.112026-04-22regular $2.36foil $3.11 2026-04-23 · regular $2.27 · foil $2.822026-04-23regular $2.27foil $2.82 2026-04-24 · regular $2.35 · foil $2.562026-04-24regular $2.35foil $2.56 2026-04-25 · regular $2.83 · foil $2.732026-04-25regular $2.83foil $2.73 2026-04-26 · regular $2.39 · foil $2.222026-04-26regular $2.39foil $2.22 2026-04-27 · regular $2.60 · foil $1.962026-04-27regular $2.60foil $1.96 2026-04-28 · regular $2.50 · foil $2.162026-04-28regular $2.50foil $2.16 2026-04-29 · regular $2.07 · foil $2.152026-04-29regular $2.07foil $2.15 2026-04-30 · regular $2.13 · foil $2.082026-04-30regular $2.13foil $2.08 2026-05-01 · regular $2.04 · foil $2.072026-05-01regular $2.04foil $2.07 2026-05-02 · regular $3.03 · foil $2.072026-05-02regular $3.03foil $2.07 2026-05-11 · regular $1.95 · foil $1.952026-05-11regular $1.95foil $1.95 2026-05-12 · regular $1.93 · foil $1.922026-05-12regular $1.93foil $1.92 2026-05-13 · regular $2.03 · foil $2.372026-05-13regular $2.03foil $2.37 2026-05-14 · regular $2.11 · foil $2.582026-05-14regular $2.11foil $2.58 2026-05-15 · regular $2.06 · foil $2.542026-05-15regular $2.06foil $2.54 2026-05-16 · regular $2.19 · foil $2.472026-05-16regular $2.19foil $2.47 2026-05-17 · regular $2.10 · foil $2.592026-05-17regular $2.10foil $2.59 2026-05-18 · regular $2.20 · foil $2.552026-05-18regular $2.20foil $2.55 2026-05-19 · regular $2.19 · foil $2.812026-05-19regular $2.19foil $2.81 2026-05-20 · regular $2.14 · foil $2.812026-05-20regular $2.14foil $2.81 2026-05-21 · regular $2.05 · foil $2.582026-05-21regular $2.05foil $2.58 2026-05-22 · regular $2.01 · foil $2.582026-05-22regular $2.01foil $2.58 2026-05-23 · regular $1.80 · foil $2.242026-05-23regular $1.80foil $2.24 2026-05-24 · regular $1.74 · foil $2.262026-05-24regular $1.74foil $2.26 2026-05-25 · regular $1.45 · foil $2.202026-05-25regular $1.45foil $2.20 2026-05-26 · regular $1.52 · foil $2.112026-05-26regular $1.52foil $2.11 2026-05-27 · regular $1.46 · foil $2.252026-05-27regular $1.46foil $2.25 2026-05-28 · regular $1.51 · foil $2.352026-05-28regular $1.51foil $2.35 2026-05-29 · regular $1.90 · foil $2.552026-05-29regular $1.90foil $2.55 2026-05-30 · regular $2.16 · foil $2.602026-05-30regular $2.16foil $2.60 2026-05-31 · regular $2.42 · foil $3.002026-05-31regular $2.42foil $3.00 2026-06-01 · regular $2.42 · foil $3.002026-06-01regular $2.42foil $3.00 2026-06-02 · regular $2.42 · foil $3.192026-06-02regular $2.42foil $3.19 2026-06-03 · regular $2.39 · foil $3.162026-06-03regular $2.39foil $3.16 2026-06-04 · regular $2.35 · foil $3.202026-06-04regular $2.35foil $3.20 2026-06-05 · regular $2.29 · foil $3.202026-06-05regular $2.29foil $3.20 2026-06-06 · regular $2.15 · foil $3.222026-06-06regular $2.15foil $3.22 2026-06-07 · regular $2.07 · foil $3.222026-06-07regular $2.07foil $3.22 2026-06-08 · regular $2.10 · foil $3.212026-06-08regular $2.10foil $3.21 2026-06-09 · regular $2.11 · foil $3.222026-06-09regular $2.11foil $3.22 2026-06-10 · regular $2.18 · foil $3.222026-06-10regular $2.18foil $3.22 2026-06-11 · regular $2.08 · foil $3.122026-06-11regular $2.08foil $3.12 2026-06-12 · regular $2.08 · foil $3.132026-06-12regular $2.08foil $3.13 2026-06-13 · regular $2.12 · foil $3.092026-06-13regular $2.12foil $3.09 2026-06-14 · regular $2.12 · foil $2.602026-06-14regular $2.12foil $2.60 2026-06-15 · regular $2.08 · foil $2.582026-06-15regular $2.08foil $2.58 2026-06-16 · regular $2.02 · foil $2.562026-06-16regular $2.02foil $2.56 2026-06-17 · regular $1.96 · foil $2.472026-06-17regular $1.96foil $2.47 2026-06-18 · regular $1.86 · foil $2.422026-06-18regular $1.86foil $2.42 2026-06-19 · regular $1.79 · foil $2.422026-06-19regular $1.79foil $2.42 2026-06-20 · regular $1.77 · foil $2.422026-06-20regular $1.77foil $2.42 2026-06-21 · regular $1.64 · foil $2.422026-06-21regular $1.64foil $2.42 2026-06-22 · regular $1.54 · foil $2.262026-06-22regular $1.54foil $2.26 2026-06-23 · regular $1.60 · foil $2.262026-06-23regular $1.60foil $2.26 2026-06-24 · regular $1.52 · foil $2.242026-06-24regular $1.52foil $2.24 2026-06-25 · regular $1.52 · foil $2.192026-06-25regular $1.52foil $2.19 2026-06-26 · regular $1.69 · foil $1.882026-06-26regular $1.69foil $1.88 2026-07-24 · regular $2.56 · foil $1.592026-07-24regular $2.56foil $1.59 2026-07-25 · regular $2.56 · foil $1.642026-07-25regular $2.56foil $1.64 2026-07-26 · regular $2.56 · foil $1.732026-07-26regular $2.56foil $1.73 2026-07-27 · regular $2.56 · foil $1.762026-07-27regular $2.56foil $1.76 2026-07-28 · regular $2.55 · foil $1.772026-07-28regular $2.55foil $1.77 2026-07-29 · regular $2.55 · foil $1.822026-07-29regular $2.55foil $1.82 2026-07-30 · regular $2.55 · foil $1.822026-07-30regular $2.55foil $1.82 2026-07-31 · regular $2.53 · foil $1.822026-07-31regular $2.53foil $1.82 2026-08-01 · regular $2.45 · foil $1.872026-08-01regular $2.45foil $1.87 2026-08-02 · regular $2.45 · foil $1.872026-08-02regular $2.45foil $1.87 2026-08-03 · regular $2.45 · foil $2.022026-08-03regular $2.45foil $2.02 2026-08-04 · regular $2.48 · foil $2.022026-08-04regular $2.48foil $2.02 2026-08-05 · regular $2.28 · foil $2.002026-08-05regular $2.28foil $2.00 2026-08-06 · regular $2.28 · foil $1.972026-08-06regular $2.28foil $1.97 2026-08-07 · regular $2.11 · foil $1.972026-08-07regular $2.11foil $1.97 2026-08-08 · regular $2.11 · foil $1.972026-08-08regular $2.11foil $1.97 2026-08-09 · regular $1.53 · foil $1.972026-08-09regular $1.53foil $1.97 2026-08-10 · regular $1.53 · foil $1.972026-08-10regular $1.53foil $1.97 2026-08-11 · regular $1.53 · foil $1.972026-08-11regular $1.53foil $1.97 2026-08-12 · regular $1.53 · foil $2.042026-08-12regular $1.53foil $2.04 2026-08-13 · regular $1.50 · foil $1.972026-08-13regular $1.50foil $1.97 2026-08-14 · regular $1.47 · foil $1.972026-08-14regular $1.47foil $1.97 2026-08-15 · regular $1.09 · foil $1.972026-08-15regular $1.09foil $1.97 2026-08-16 · regular $1.08 · foil $1.972026-08-16regular $1.08foil $1.97 2026-08-17 · regular $1.01 · foil $1.972026-08-17regular $1.01foil $1.97 2026-08-18 · regular $1.03 · foil $1.982026-08-18regular $1.03foil $1.98 2026-08-19 · regular $1.03 · foil $1.982026-08-19regular $1.03foil $1.98 2026-08-20 · regular $1.03 · foil $1.982026-08-20regular $1.03foil $1.98 2026-08-21 · regular $1.03 · foil $1.982026-08-21regular $1.03foil $1.98 2026-08-22 · regular $0.97 · foil $1.892026-08-22regular $0.97foil $1.89 2026-08-23 · regular $0.99 · foil $1.832026-08-23regular $0.99foil $1.83 2026-08-24 · regular $0.97 · foil $1.812026-08-24regular $0.97foil $1.81 2026-08-25 · regular $0.96 · foil $1.852026-08-25regular $0.96foil $1.85 2026-08-28 · regular $0.90 · foil $1.762026-08-28regular $0.90foil $1.76 2026-08-29 · regular $0.90 · foil $1.762026-08-29regular $0.90foil $1.76 2026-08-30 · regular $0.88 · foil $1.722026-08-30regular $0.88foil $1.72 2026-08-31 · regular $0.90 · foil $1.582026-08-31regular $0.90foil $1.58 2026-09-01 · regular $0.97 · foil $1.482026-09-01regular $0.97foil $1.48 2026-09-02 · regular $1.00 · foil $1.442026-09-02regular $1.00foil $1.44 2026-09-03 · regular $1.00 · foil $1.442026-09-03regular $1.00foil $1.44 2026-09-04 · regular $1.01 · foil $1.472026-09-04regular $1.01foil $1.47 2026-09-05 · regular $1.05 · foil $1.442026-09-05regular $1.05foil $1.44 2026-09-06 · regular $1.10 · foil $1.422026-09-06regular $1.10foil $1.42 2026-09-08 · regular $1.19 · foil $1.422026-09-08regular $1.19foil $1.42 2026-09-09 · regular $1.19 · foil $1.442026-09-09regular $1.19foil $1.44 2026-09-10 · regular $1.19 · foil $1.462026-09-10regular $1.19foil $1.46 2026-09-11 · regular $1.19 · foil $1.462026-09-11regular $1.19foil $1.46 2026-09-12 · regular $1.21 · foil $1.462026-09-12regular $1.21foil $1.46 2026-09-13 · regular $1.21 · foil $1.502026-09-13regular $1.21foil $1.50 2026-09-14 · regular $1.21 · foil $1.502026-09-14regular $1.21foil $1.50 2026-09-15 · regular $1.21 · foil $1.522026-09-15regular $1.21foil $1.52 2026-09-16 · regular $1.20 · foil $1.522026-09-16regular $1.20foil $1.52 2026-09-17 · regular $1.20 · foil $1.522026-09-17regular $1.20foil $1.52 2026-09-19 · regular $1.21 · foil $1.442026-09-19regular $1.21foil $1.44 2026-09-20 · regular $1.21 · foil $1.442026-09-20regular $1.21foil $1.44 2026-09-21 · regular $1.19 · foil $1.432026-09-21regular $1.19foil $1.43 2026-09-22 · regular $1.20 · foil $1.432026-09-22regular $1.20foil $1.43 2026-09-23 · regular $1.26 · foil $1.432026-09-23regular $1.26foil $1.43 2026-09-24 · regular $1.26 · foil $1.452026-09-24regular $1.26foil $1.45 2026-09-25 · regular $1.27 · foil $1.422026-09-25regular $1.27foil $1.42 2026-09-26 · regular $1.27 · foil $1.422026-09-26regular $1.27foil $1.42 2026-09-27 · regular $1.27 · foil $1.422026-09-27regular $1.27foil $1.42 2026-04-05 2026-09-27
regular foil · 125 days tracked · $28.00 → $1.27 (-95%) · low $0.88 · high $60.00
Daily USD snapshots; a flat stretch is a day with no new price recorded.

Other languages

The same printing (Secrets of Strixhaven #358) in 5 other languages.

Store prices

The 3 cheapest per condition and finish, in stock at the last check. Offers not re-confirmed within 60 days are not shown.

StoreConditionFinishPriceChecked
Face To Face GamesNM · todayNMregularCA$0.99today
Card KingdomNM · yesterdayNMregular$1.29yesterday
CardmarketNM · todayNMregular€1.42today
Face To Face GamesNM · foil · todayNMfoilCA$1.49today
CardmarketNM · foil · todayNMfoil€1.62today
401 GamesSP · foil · 2 days agoSPfoilCA$2.702 days ago
The Mystic StoreSP · 2 days agoSPregularCA$2.992 days ago
401 GamesNM · foil · 2 days agoNMfoilCA$3.002 days ago
Magic StrongholdSP · foil · yesterdaySPfoilCA$4.75yesterday

Truncated: 9 further offers are available at a higher price in the same conditions, out of 18 in total.

Format legality

  • standard: legal
  • pioneer: legal
  • modern: legal
  • legacy: legal
  • vintage: legal
  • commander: legal
  • pauper: not legal
  • brawl: legal

In Gestic collections

  • Held in 5 lists
  • 7 copies tracked

All printings of Traumatic Critique

USD · low $0.65 · high $1.27

Set#RarityUSD
Secrets of Strixhaven#239 · rare239rare$0.82
Secrets of Strixhaven#358 · rare358rare$1.27
Secrets of Strixhaven Promos#239p · rare239prare$0.65